1. Toasted Marshmallow, Stand, 24 East 12th Street.
2. Dulce de Leche, Mary’s Dairy, 171 West 4th Street.
3. Hudson Valley Vanilla, Ronnybrook Farm, Chelsea Market.
4. Black & White Malt, Shake Shack, Madison Square Park.
5. Mocha Mudslide, BLT burger, 470 6th Avenue.